Quick Exit
FORUMS

Connect with people who understand what you are going through, seek advice and surround yourself with support. We're free, anonymous, and professionally moderated 24/7.

  • 47,612Members
  • 1,358,869Posts
  • 1,400,000Visitors
Friends, families and carers
Friends, families and carers

How much help is too much?

How much help is too much?

Hi, my 24 year old son has been experiencing some mental health challenges. We are currently waiting on appointments for a comprehensive psychiatric assessment - after several different medications have been unsuccessful. His mental health is quite episodic. He is currently on a job seeker payment with a medical exemption saying he doesn't need to be applying for jobs. He has a causal job with an amazing boss - some weeks he doesn't manage to make it in to work at all, others he manages four shifts etc. His government payment changes according to how much he has earnt that week. The way his pay cycle works it sometimes means he has a week with very little money - his government payment is fortnightly and if he had a good fortnight at work he gets very little government money but then if he has a setback and can't make it to work he gets no wage and it can take a week or two for the government money to catch up - leaving him with no money. My husband and I help out when we can but are reluctant to keep doing this - first, because it puts us under extra financial strain but also because I fear we are making him too dependant on us. He lives with a mate and often can't afford his rent - he is able to move home but his independence is extremely important to him and moving back home actually makes his mental state worse as he becomes despondent and his self esteem plummets. We are trying to help him set up his budget with a reserve fund that he can draw on during those weeks he has no pay but his impulse control is not great and if he has money he just spends it - eg he'll have no money for petrol or rent but we will notice he has new shoes etc. We have told him we can help with his budgeting but can't continue to give him money and "bail him out". 

 

My question is, when it comes to his finances, how much support is too much? We had an idea to set up an account that requires joint authorisation for withdrawals - all his wages and government money would go in here - his rent and other bills will be debited form here and he will receive a weekly amount into his spending account for extras - entertainment etc. He will have full control over his spending account but any money withdrawn from the reserve account will need either myself or my husband to approve it. He is keen for this arrangement, the money belongs to him and anytime he decides he no longer wants our authority attached to the account we will remove ourselves no questions asked. Is this to "controlling"?? Is it making him too dependent? His psychologist told us he needed a bit of "benign neglect" when we were paying his rent too often etc which is why we are stopping that - I don't want to just completely withdraw all our support though and this seemed like a way we can support him to do things himself with a bit of extra guidance until he is on his feet. Is this mollycoddling or worse, coercive control?

3 replies

In response to: How much help is too much?

Re: How much help is too much?

@Mumto4 very much NOT Coercive Control

 

That's pretty much the only input I have, sorry. At that point in my life, I was kind of between families with nobody

In response to: Re: How much help is too much?

Re: How much help is too much?

@DogMan79  Thank you, I really need to hear that actually - one of my biggest fears is that I don't want to "control" him, just guide and support him

In response to: How much help is too much?

Re: How much help is too much?

Hi @Mumto4 

 

It sounds to me that you are helping him in the most responsible manner possible while he is going through a difficult period and waiting to get him in for a comprehensive mental health assessment. I seriously question his psychologist saying that he needs “benign neglect” at this stage, it sounds like absolutely awful advice and I encourage you to keep supporting him in the positive ways you are. It seems to be a very reasonable level of supportive to be doing for a loved one in this situation. 
Wishing both you and your son all the best on this journey and I encourage you to continue to support him in the ways you are. 🙏 

Reply to thread

to reply.